cigar
close but no cigar (of an attempt) almost but not quite successful. North American informal
☞ This phrase possibly originated as a consoling comment to or about a man who put up a good, but not winning, performance in a competition or especially a fairground test of strength in which the prize was a cigar.
2010Guardian He's too old to be in porn, and it's the wrong month for nude calendars. So who is he: the newest Chippendale? Close, but no cigar. He's the former ballet dancer who is now White House chief of staff.