judge (one) on (one's) own merits

judge (one) on (one's) own merits

To form an opinion, estimation, or determination about one based solely on one's own strengths and weaknesses, to the exclusion of any other related person or thing. I know my father was an incredible actor, but I just want to be judged on my own merits. I know there is a lot of controversy surrounding the company she previously worked for, but, judged on her own merits, she's definitely the best fit for the job.
See also: judge, merit, on, own
Farlex Dictionary of Idioms.

judge one on one's own merits

to evaluate one on one's own good and bad points and no one else's. Please judge Janet on her own merits. I was judged on my own merits.
See also: judge, merit, on, one, own
McGraw-Hill Dictionary of American Idioms and Phrasal Verbs.
See also:
  • judge one on own merits
  • merit
  • judge (something) on its own merits
  • judge on its own merits
  • judge between
  • judge between (someone or something) (and someone or something else)
  • thyself
  • know thyself
  • beat (one) at (one's) own game
  • beat someone at his or her own game